We already had a vague idea that we would be in for
a treat for the second class as well. My prediction was right. Dr.T.Prasad
entered the class with his armour of toys and knowledge. This time it was a
tower building experiment. We were asked to predict the height of the tower
with respect to the number of blocks that can be stacked one over the other. Many
voices came up with different numbers and finally a count was fixed for both
the following experiment.
Experiment 1(Craft Management):
A student was asked to arrange the blocks one over
the other. He took his time and skilfully stacked up the blocks. There were
certain times where the tower suffered the risk of falling and finally the
student was able to construct a 22 block tower.
Experiment 2(Modern Management):
Three students were called and they were given
respective designations like CEO(S1), Manager(S2), Worker(S3). S1 gave the idea
to S2 that what should be done. S2, in turn explained the work to S3. S3 was
blindfolded. The job of S3 was to do the job as S2 gave instructions and build
the tower. The team was able to manage a commendable 27 block tower.
My Learnings are tabulated as follows:
PARAMETER
|
CRAFT MANAGEMENT(Old School)
|
MODERN MANAGEMENT(New School)
|
WORK
|
Only one person does the work,
hence the work becomes highly ambiguous |
Many persons will do the work,
hence the work becomes crystal clear |
SATISFACTION
|
The satisfaction level will be high
as he does the complete work on his own. |
The satisfaction level will be less as
the work gets divided and workers working space becomes narrow. |
TIME
|
Time taken will be more as he has
the complete the work single handedly |
Time taken will be less as the work
is divided |
SKILL
|
Since he does the work on his own,
skill set will be high |
As a worker is restricted to a single
domain, his skill set will be less |
PRODUCTIVITY
|
Productivity is less
|
Productivity is more
|
Hence, Modern Management overtakes Craft Management
when the parameters are weighed on Time, Work, Productivity which plays a major
role in the present scenario in any organization.